Crime Archive

You need to download and install Flash to see this clip

Mistakes Most Foul!

Have bodies been found with marks that suggested murder and consequently send innocent people to jail?

Well, it certainly seems possible now after the the latest forensic news claims that some lesions, cuts and marks found on corpses which could have lead pathologists towards murderous conclusion have in fact been caused by insects. Entomology and forensics usually helped determine the timing of death but now it seems that insects have been responsible for many marks which prosecutors have previously suggested were caused by third parties.

A body of evidence ( forgive the pun) gathered by Dr Stefan Vanin from the University of Huddersfield makes the cases the "many of the lesions on a dead body which resemble injuries and wounds left by human perpetrators" were actually caused by tiny insects. One wonders just how many people have been accused of murder and manslaughter on the basis of injuries caused after death by insects. Dr Vanin says that ants scavenging over the face of a dead person can leave tiny 'deposit marks' that can be interpreted as a punch in Forensic Science International.

The world of forensics is not quite as cut and dried as the CSI shows indicate and the advance of technology is introducing as much doubt as certainty and those who covered and witnessed the forensic evidence offered during the trial of the Birmingham Six will always treat forensic evidence as scientific opinion rather than scientific fact.

But it's not just post-mortem injuries caused by insects that get the innocent into trouble - there is one rare childhood illness that leaves bruises and marks on the skin but which has been misdiagnosed as abuse and resulted in children being taken away from their parents. HSP, or Henoch-Schonlein purpura is an auto-immune disease which causes inflammation under the skin, in the bowel and stomach and leaves specific purple bruising from the soles of the feet to the buttocks. Crucially, the marks do not go above the waist.

The marks starts as red blotches and then graduate into purple marks under the skin. The symptoms can come in mixed waves, sometimes just stomach pains are apparent and sometimes just the marks and although most of the sufferers grow out of their symptoms for those who have recurring HSP, death occurs in five per cent of cases.

Doctors often mistake the stomach pains for acute appendicitis and also misdiagnose the bruises for abuse. I became aware of this condition after my little girl, Tiger, became very unwell about two years ago and a diagnosis was very hard to determine until one consultant put the symptoms together. It dawned upon me that there must be a huge number of parents who have been accused of abuse on the basis of this distressing disease. There are specific tests which can confirm the diagnosis but often when social workers, Police and mistaken doctors decide a path it is very hard to get them to change their opinion.

There are a range of other childhood illnesses which mimic abuse and there is no doubt that protecting children is the priority but doctors and professional must be careful not to rush to judgement.

A sober thought for those who give too much credence to scientific and medical expert opinion. I, for one, am just grateful for Great Ormond St Hospital who have the expertise and the skills to treat my little princess. She is well and thankfully now on the road to recovery.

Send Article to a Friend

Back to Top of Page

Free Spring Health Check from VW

Yourlocal.ie

Find Local Security and Legal

Burglar Alarm Systems
Insurance Brokers
Locksmiths
Solicitors

Find more Legal in your area on Yourlocal.ie


Back to Top of Page

Donal MacIntyre

Crime Correspondents with the Sunday World

The Dolphin Snatchers

Our man Donal helps to release flippers into wild after they are captured and kept outside nightclub for tourists

FREEDOM: Donal McIntyre with dolphins as they prepare for releaseTHEY ARE the majestic princes of the sea. But the magnetic appeal of dolphins has now placed them at the centre of an ugly international trade involving tourists, shadowy former Russian military figures and the entertainment industry.

Five years ago two male bottlenose dolphins were swimming off the coast of northern Turkey when they were captured and dragged from the depths. It began a horrific and extraordinary journey that saw them driven in a van, dumped in a tiny nightclub pool for the amusement of tourists before eventually being rescued and helped by the world-renowned expert who returned the famous Free Willy whale Keiko to the seas.

This week the two dolphins, Tom and Misha, were freed back into the blue from where they had been snatched to service a growing trade where tourists, many of them Irish, will pay to swim with dolphins in captivity.

Rogue

TENSE TIME: Locals are drafted in to help dolphins to safety Rogue cowboys of the sea still roam the waters of the Mediterranean and the Aegean, trapping wild dolphins for sale into the tourist and research industries. Turkey has now become caught up in the terrible trade in stolen dolphins, as tourist resorts offer visitors the chance to swim with these intelligent mammals.

Naturally, they are never told the animals were taken illegally from the wild or of the cruelties involved in the training and keeping of dolphins in tiny pools and aquariums.

Tom and Misha were captured and brutally hauled on to trawlers five years ago and bought by a Russian businessman for the tourist trade. They were placed in a rusty vegetable van and transported for hours over mountainous roads to a cesspit of a nightclub pool where they would spend two years of hell. The Russians took a stranglehold in this cruel trade after their own dolphin military programs were scaled down, leaving literally hundreds of mammals abandoned and their trainers out of work.

Trained to be armed torpedoes and mine hunters, some of these ex-military dolphins are now swimming with tourists in Israel and Turkey. With the Russian money came the Russian mafia and dealing with these dolphin owners was fraught with difficulty and mired in threats and violence.

The pool at Hirasanu, in southern Turkey, where Tom and Misha ended up, was filled with poisonous water and was dangerous to both the unwitting tourists and the traumatised dolphins.

As the scandal of the dolphins' plight became known, this reporter was called in to negotiate their return back into responsible hands. In smokefilled rooms, the bargaining began and lasted three months. Each dolphin was worth €250,000 and many workers depended on the pool for a living.The Russian owner had just fled leaving a pile of debts and two dolphins in a perilous state.

TENSE TIME: Locals are drafted in to help dolphins to safety It led to a tense stand-off between workers and campaigners from Dolphin Angels, a local group of expat Irish and English women who first raised concerns.

"We will shoot the dolphins or maybe we will take them to the sea ourselves," the workers told me.

During the day the roar of traffic disturbed the animals' sonar and at night music blared from the club next door to add to the horrors. And still Irish tourists believed they were going to share a spiritual experience with these beautiful animals. They were not to know how sick the animals were. In the end, Tom and Misha were listing to one side, unable to get stable buoyancy for themselves and their tender skin was covered with sores and blisters.

The bureaucracy of local corrupt officials meant that there were other hurdles to overcome, but finally wildlife foundation Born Free made a deal to pay off some of the workers' debts and take the animals to a secret sanctuary in the Aegean Sea, about two hours drive from the Turkish town of Dalman.

This was the first step towards recovery in August 2010 and in January 2011 Jeff Foster began to train the animals for their release.
Jeff was previously involved in the wild capture of dolphins and killer whales, but now has renounced that work and spends his time on conservation projects all around the world.

Perfect

SAVIOUR: Marine expert Jeff Foster nursed dolphins back to health "Tom and Misha have survived terrible sickness to get where they are.They have been so traumatised by their captivity that there was only a 50/50 chance of survival," he said.

"These odds have now improved and we have the best of hope for them on their release."

As dawn broke on a perfect day in the marine reserve this week, it seemed that the impossible was going to happen, that the dolphins would return to their natural home. The last minutes before their release were fraught with difficulty, as both animals had to be tagged with satellite and radio transmitters.

"They are unusually tense as they know something momentous is happening, but they are not sure what," Jeff explained.

In the company of the Dolphin Angels, the rehab team and Born Free founder Virginia McKenna, the door that separated them from the sea was opened (left).

"They were grinning as they left," the underwater cameraman said as they swam free.

By the end of the first day they had swam 30 miles and, crucially, were joined by a third dolphin, a pal with whom to share the adventure.

Send Article to a Friend

Back to Top of Page

Articles from the Archives

Display All Related Archives

Back to Top of Page